blog

Cyber insurance is no longer a luxury—it’s a necessity. But here’s the uncomfortable truth: having a policy doesn’t guarantee protection. In fact, according to Cowbell’s 2025 Cyber Claims Report, over 33,000 cyber insurance claims were filed in the U.S. last year, yet a significant portion were either delayed or denied due to poor cybersecurity hygiene and documentation.

So, what’s going wrong—and how can your business avoid becoming another statistic?

The Illusion of Coverage: What Most Businesses Miss

Cyber insurance is designed to help organizations recover from digital disasters. Depending on your policy, it may cover:

• Data recovery and system restoration
• Legal and regulatory costs
• Customer notification and credit monitoring
• Business interruption losses
• Ransom payments (in some cases)

But insurers don’t just write checks. They investigate. If your cybersecurity posture doesn’t meet their standards, your claim could be rejected—leaving you to absorb the full cost of the breach.

Why Claims Get Denied (Even When You’re Insured)

Many businesses are blindsided when their claims are denied. Common reasons include:

• Missing or outdated security controls
• Unpatched systems and software
• Lack of documentation
• No formal incident response plan

In short, if you can’t prove you were doing your part to protect your systems, your insurer may walk away.

How to Build a Cyber-Ready Business

To avoid costly surprises, your cybersecurity practices must align with what insurers expect. Here’s how to get there:

1. Lock Down the Basics

Implement multi-factor authentication (MFA), endpoint protection, and reliable backup systems.

2. Document Everything

Maintain a clear, up-to-date incident response plan and keep records of your security protocols.

3. Stay Current

Regularly patch and update all systems. Outdated software is a red flag for insurers—and hackers.

4. Train Your Team

Cybersecurity isn’t just IT’s job. Ongoing employee training is essential to reduce human error.

5. Assess and Adapt

Conduct regular risk assessments and act on the findings. Show your insurer you’re proactive, not reactive.

Why the Right IT Partner Matters

Navigating cyber insurance requirements can be complex. A trusted IT partner can help you:

• Implement insurer-approved security controls
• Prepare documentation for audits or claims
• Stay ahead of evolving threats and compliance standards

Final Thought: Insurance Is a Safety Net, Not a Strategy

Cyber insurance is a smart investment—but it’s not a substitute for strong cybersecurity. Think of it as your financial backup plan, not your first line of defense. By strengthening your security posture now, you’ll not only reduce your risk—you’ll also ensure your coverage actually counts when it matters most.